Rules update: The overwhelming consensus is for the rules changes, although a discernible number (5) are uncomfortable making the change after the season has started. Although I do appreciate that, since we’re not to June yet it’s hard to imagine that there is any overuse issue that can’t be resolved by September, nor will continually over-using a player for the next 4 months likely produce a playoff strategy. There is certainly something to setting the precedent that we should NEVER change a rule after the season starts, but in this instance that seems to be outweighed by (a) the fact that the rule change is happening early enough that everyone has a fair and equal chance to adapt to it, and (b) the obviousness of the problem the rule will definitively fix. So, this should not set a precedent for allowing rules changes at any point where they will advantage some teams over others. We’ll go for the rules change and make it for this year. I will clarify that playoff stats will NOT affect the over-use numbers; they will be frozen at whatever point they are on the last day of the season. Essentially, playoff AB and IP will NOT count toward over-use. The strategy issue will be to enter the playoffs without substantial player over-use.
FEAT OF THE WEEK: Brett Lawrie of TOR hit for the cycle against DET on 5/17/2011
COMMENTS: No NL division leader is up by more than 1.5 games…8 NL teams are within 2.5 games of first, and no AL 2nd-place team is closer than 4.5…The trade that made both teams better? The Mets and Giants swapped 10 players and had a combined record of 13-1…Houston is a ridiculous +10 WOR and making noise in the NL central after a 6-1 week…Baltimore and Boston made moves in the AL East…4 of the 5 NL West teams have positive WOR…Ramon Hernandez of Cincinnati had 5 HR but only 8 RBI last week, perhaps because teammate Scott Rolen knocked in 11, keeping the bases relatively clear…Cleveland leads the ASFBL with 77 HR, 11 more than the nearest competitor…St. Louis leads the ASFBL with a team BA of .292…Oakland has a fantasy team ERA of 3.02, which is very good and very close to the actual team ERA, but in the ASFBL the Angels are even better at 2.76…The fantasy Angels now have both players named Francisco Rodriguez…The San Diego bullpen has allowed a miniscule 5% of inherited runners to score.
FEATS AND FAILURES: Scott Rolen of CIN had 5 hits against CHC on 5/17/2011…Jason Vargas of NYM had 12 strikeouts against WAS on 5/18/2011…Tim Lincecum of BOS had 12 strikeouts against DET on 5/18/2011…Alex Avila of DET struck out 4 times against BOS on 5/18/2011…Omar Vizquel of CWS had 5 hits against CLE on 5/19/2011…Nate Schierholtz of HOU robbed 3 hits against TOR on 5/20/2011…Nate Schierholtz of HOU struck out 4 times against TOR on 5/21/2011